Is the adjective "ultra-linear" exclusively associated with high-fidelity, audio reproduction amplifiers? Hardly. Many would be surprised to learn that the 200-watt Marshall Model 1967 head was an ultralinear power amp. So was the Sunn Model T Super. Even Fender built an ultralinear amp.
Despite their lack of popularity amongst today's guitar players, for guitar amp designers ultralinear amplifiers reveal important details about the inner workings of triodes, pentodes, and beam power tubes in the context of a push-pull amplifier. Understanding the nuances of ultralinear design provides valuable insight into how a power amp works.
Consider the classic push-pull guitar amplifier power amp, where the screens are connected directly to the plate supply.
Normally there is an intervening choke or resistor combined with a large capacitor to provide hum filtering and DC voltage regulation, but if the high-voltage DC power source is provided by a theoretically perfect high-voltage battery of constant voltage, as shown, then we can avoid this tedious complication. (The virtual reality of a drawing posted to the Internet, in contrast to a real amp operating on your test bench, is wonderful this regard.)
Here we see the normal configuration for a guitar amplifier power amp, where the screens are held to a relatively constant voltage and the plates are connected to the high-voltage supply via the output transformer load. Under these circumstances the screen has a much greater influence on the flow of current through the tube, because it is closer to the cathode, but amazingly it abstains from exercising its influence, thereby granting full control to the grid. The plate voltage varies over a wide range, but has little influence over the plate current. It is nothing more than a helpless bystander through which torrents of electrons flow almost completely beyond its control. The constant screen and the signal-varying grid determine the current through the load. This is classic pentode operation.
When we connect the screen of a pentode or beam power tetrode directly to the plate, the two electrodes electrically act as one. They combine to create a mechanically interesting, if electrically simple, composite electrode. The screen and the plate together become just a single plate. We create a simple triode out of what originally was a multi-grid tube.
The tube is now "triode connected." Together the screen and plate act together as a weirdly manufactured, but nevertheless effective plate. As the plate voltages of the power tubes vary, they greatly affect electron flow, just as in a triode. In particular, as the signal voltage at the grid increases, current through the output transformer increases, which causes a greater voltage drop across it. This lowers the plate-and-screen voltage and counteracts the increase in current created by the grid's signal voltage. We don't see this effect in a normally-configured guitar amp power stage.
When we connect the screens to taps on the power transformer primary, the tubes operate at a point somewhere between pure-pentode and pure-triode operation.
The closer the taps are to the plate, the more the screen voltage varies with plate voltage and the more the pentode acts like a triode. Connecting the screens in this way can be seen as having pentodes with negative feedback. When the plate current increases, the screen voltage decreases, counteracting the increase in plate current, not as much as a triode plate, but substantial nonetheless.
Connecting the screens in this way can be seen as having pentodes with negative feedback. When the plate current increases, the screen voltage decreases, counteracting the increased plate current.
The screen taps in output transformers designed for ultralinear operation are typically set to 43 percent of the primary winding, which is the point of minimum distortion. (This is perhaps why the ultralinear nature of some classic amps are apparently are not widely advertised by their creators.) Since impedance varies as the square of the number of turns, the primary impedance for a power tube screen is 18.5 percent of the primary impedance for the plate.
Maximum power is achieved with the taps at 20 percent of the primary winding, which corresponds to 4 percent of the primary impedance. In other words, much more pentode and less audiophile triode. Perhaps a better choice for a distortion-salivating stadium amp.
David Hafler and Herbert Keroes introduce the expression "ultra-linear" in a 1951 article published in Audio Engineering:1
"We have achieved a new tube type without designing a new tube. This tube is neither triode nor tetrode, but its improved linearity over either of these types justifies the designation ultra-linear."
They also created the company Acrosound to sell output transformers with ultralinear screen taps in the primary. Hafler received a US Patent for the invention with a drawing that shows the distinctive taps that are key to the ultralinear concept.2
An article published in a respected publication and a US Patent are quite convincing evidence of ownership. I myself got it wrong, as readers of an early edition of one of my books were quick to point out. It turns out that Alan Blumlein patented this invention more than a decade earlier. His patent drawing clearly shows a single-ended design that demonstrates the concept in its most fundamental form: a vacuum tube that is neither triode-connected nor pentode-connected. It is operating somewhere in between.4
1David Hafler and Herbert I. Keroes, "An Ultra-Linear Amplifier," Audio Engineering, Nov 1951, pp. 15-17.
3Richard Kuehnel, Vacuum-Tube Circuit Design: Guitar Amplifier Power Amps, (Seattle: Pentode Press, 2008).
Copyright © 2005-2015 Amp Books LLC All Rights Reserved